Percy Jackson and the Lightening Thief

So when Percy Jackson came out I was actually very excited, it looked like a clever idea, looked fun and the CGI looked great. Plus I love movies that have lots of actors I know and this movie was overflowing with movie actors and TV actors that I know. Like Logan Lerman who was in my sisters favourite series Jack and Bobby, and Stella from CSI: New York playing Athena and Dr Hunt from Grey’s Anatomy playing Poseidon, Sean Bean playing Zeus and Pierce Brosnan playing Chiron (yeh never saw Pierce Brosnan as a horsey guy), Rosario Dawson plays Persephone, Uma Thurman plays Medusa. And the chick playing Annabeth is gorgeous. So I got my friends together and we watched the evening showing and it was fun. I’m not saying I’m going to go out and buy all the merchandise ‘n stuff, but it was a good movie. Of course I did wish that there were movies like this when I was a little girl.

Percy Jackson the movie is actually an adaption of the book by Rick Riordan. I found a cheapie copy on take2.co.za (most awesome site for cheap books and DVD’s, it’s local and has a LARGE variety) and when I got it I settled down to read it. Apart from knowing who the lightening thief is because of the movie, I was quite shocked to discover that the book it HUGELY different to the movie. Ok, yes this happens a lot, but recently the book adaptations I have seen have been pretty faithful.

Mostly it’s the overall motives of the Lightening Thief, and Percy and his quest that differ from the book to the movie. And if they wanted to make Percy Jackson into a series of movies which is the trend in Hollywood at the moment like Harry Potter, Narnia, Twilight, Last Airbender, Lord of the Rings, they messed it up with Percy Jackson.

I shall explain why:

MINOR SPOILER WARNING:

The lightening thief did not steal only Zeus’s Thunderbolt! He stole other things from the Gods. He also had the assistance from another God. But ultimately the lightening thief serves someone older than the Olympian Gods! I speak in code so any of you who do Greek and Roman history might have guessed who this big bad really is! AND the Lightening thief gets away at the end of the first book. Now in the next four books the Lightening Thief is constantly going up against Percy and his friends.

Also, on Percy’s quest, there is no Hydra, and the pearls that help them escape the Underworld are a gift from Poseidon, and are also not the main reason they travelled all over the country, not to find the missing pearls.

In the book they go to all the different places because firstly they have to do a job for Ares the God of War, and then they have to go to the ocean to have a meeting with a messenger of Poseidon. 

Persephone was not home when they went to visit Hades.

Percy fights Echidna and a Chimera (his interactions with Echidna are so funny and witty).

The scene where they fight Medusa is a chapter in the book, less than 10 pages, and super short!

 Annabeth and Grover have a history together, and it’s full of death and sadness. This back story comes into major play in later books!

I really loved the writing style of Percy Jackson. It’s fast paced and extremely funny. It was very reminisce to the Maximum Ride books by James Patterson and the Mortal Instruments Trilogy by Cassandra Clare. (Both awesome authors check them out!) The only flaw is that it seems a lot of the time the reader is smarter than the main character, you figure out the threats before the main character does. Actually it’s most probably because I have a better knowledge of Greek mythology than the intended audience, and also because the book is aimed at 8-12 years olds. (Yes I can hear you laughing, I feel no shame, and it’s more interesting than adult fantasy which is about sex and politics!)

The sequel was a bit of a letdown. It reminded me of the second Pirates of the Caribbean movie, it was trying too hard to be action packed and funny, so comedy never felt natural and the action was a bit boring. But the good news is that the author got his groove back in the third book and it was a brilliant fast-paced, funny read. The Percy Jackson series is a fun read, and if the first movie had been done properly, a good movie franchise could follow. But I think I’ll stick to the books. Man I’m dying to start the fourth book.

Advertisements

4 thoughts on “Percy Jackson and the Lightening Thief

  1. I actually just finished The Lightening Thief. My brother showed it to me yesterday that he borrowed it from a friend and it hasnt left my room (or my hands really). It was a really light, quick and easy read. I always loved Greek Mythology when I was younger, not that I knew much, but always found it cool. I liked that it was different from the movie – and that the movie stood so well on its own; taking a few elements and tying them together into the basic storyline. The book is just like extra info and fun. I like reading about the “hero’s journey”, almost Harry Potterish but not as detailed as Rowling. I feel sometimes things could have been more detailed, but then again the audience is much younger than me lol! So I think its well written for its target 🙂

  2. I agree, as a children’s book Lightening Thief is top notch. I like this kind of fast paced writing. i also loved greek mythology, my sister does classics now and she comes home and tells me all about the greek gods sexual prefferences and incest. ew. BUT Percy Jackson is an awesome series i encourage you to continue reading the series.

  3. I’ll hopefully be getting the next book from my brother this week, and am pretty excited to read it 🙂

  4. i started the fourth book, and its really good, but life got in the way and i know that if i start reading again i’ll have to finish the book, and i dont have the time, which is rich because the percy jackson books are super short quick reads. enjoy the second, its full of surprises! 🙂

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out / Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out / Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out / Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out / Change )

Connecting to %s